Sheila's Royal Castle Restaurant on Queens Highway in Tarpum Bay mainly concentrates on chicken, and conch. They also have excellent sandwiches. You can either dine in, or take out. There is an old nightclub, and dining hall inside, which can be used for special events, like weddings.
See some pictures of diving at Cape Eleuthera, with Sheila's late husband, Garfield, as well as some Hollywood Celebrities. See if you recognize them???