Historic Sites & Landmarks of Eleuthera
A Journey Through Time
Eleuthera is more than breathtaking beaches and turquoise waters. It is an island layered with history—from early settlement to maritime trade and spiritual foundations.
Here are some of Eleuthera’s most significant historic landmarks.
Why Historic Sites Matter
Eleuthera’s landmarks tell the story of freedom, faith, trade, resilience, and survival. They remind us that the island was shaped by:
- Indigenous roots
- Religious migration
- Maritime trade
- Agricultural strength
- Community growth
Exploring these sites connects visitors not just to scenery—but to story.
Preacher’s Cave
North Eleuthera
Preacher’s Cave is considered the birthplace of European settlement in Eleuthera.
In 1648, the Eleutheran Adventurers sought shelter here after arriving from Bermuda in search of religious freedom. The cave provided protection, fresh water nearby, and a gathering place for worship.
Today, visitors can walk inside this limestone cave and reflect on the island’s early beginnings.
Glass Window Bridge
North Eleuthera
Often called the “narrowest place on Earth,” the Glass Window Bridge sits atop dramatic cliffs where the deep blue Atlantic Ocean meets the calm turquoise Caribbean Sea.
Originally a natural rock arch, storms eventually destroyed the formation, and the bridge was built in its place.
The contrast in watercolors makes it one of the most photographed spots in The Bahamas.
St. Patrick’s Anglican Church
Governor's Harbour
Built in the early 1800s, St. Patrick’s Anglican Church is one of Eleuthera’s historic churches and remains an active place of worship.
The church reflects British colonial architecture and the strong role faith played in the development of early settlements.
Its white exterior and peaceful setting overlooking the harbor give visitors a glimpse into Eleuthera’s spiritual heritage.
Cupid's Cay
Governor's Harbour
Cupid’s Cay was once the center of Eleuthera’s early settlement activity.
This narrow peninsula in Governor’s Harbour contains some of the island’s oldest homes, many dating back to the 1800s. The architecture reflects Loyalist influence and maritime trade history.
Walking through Cupid’s Cay feels like stepping back in time.
Hatchet Bay Cave
Central Eleuthera
One of the largest cave systems in The Bahamas, Hatchet Bay Cave stretches underground with intricate limestone formations.
Originally used for shelter and exploration, it later became a point of curiosity for visitors and researchers alike.
Today, guided tours offer a safe way to explore this natural historic landmark.
Ocean Hole
Rock Sound
Ocean Hole is a natural inland blue hole located in Rock Sound.
Connected to the ocean through underground channels, it has long fascinated residents and visitors. Local stories and legends surround the site, adding mystery to its natural beauty.
It remains a popular stop for swimming and sightseeing.